The voice-learning panel produced 81 vetted style lessons — all stuck at
review_status='proposed' with 0 ever approved — so the writer (which reads only
'approved') received NONE of them. The system captured learning but never let it
flow. Chair decision (2026-06-28): a GRADUATED gate by content risk.
- STYLE lessons (categories style/structure/lexicon/tabular) the 2/2 panel kept →
created as review_status='approved' → flow to the writer immediately, reversibly
(chair vetoes in /training). The deepseek+gemini panel only emits style_method
and only on 2/2 consensus, so this is exactly the gate's criterion; substance is
already filtered out and skipped, and routes through the strict halacha gate.
- SUBSTANCE (halacha/precedent/fact) stays a HARD chair gate — unchanged.
style_lesson_panel.py: _review_status_for(category) sets the gate explicitly
(approved for _STYLE_CATEGORIES, else proposed); the apply loop passes it to
db.add_decision_lesson (which already accepts review_status — no DB change).
Spec: INV-LRN1 rewritten as the graduated gate (hard for substance; reversible
auto-flow for consensus style — still "under user control" via veto, per
NCSC/CEPEJ); §0.6 updated to match.
A one-time backfill of the 81 existing panel style lessons to 'approved' runs
separately (DB, post-merge).
Invariants: INV-LRN1 (amended — graduated), INV-LRN5 (style-only, substance never
auto-flows), G10 (human control preserved as reversible veto).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Chaim
044de2c0f0